The Wicker Basket Baby - Infant Mortality
69The Accomplices
On November 30th, 1933, just as the owner of a gas station and grocery store was closing up, he was robbed at gun point, by a young couple who had no Bonnie and Clyde talents. The bungling young man's disguise couldn't conceal the fact that the victim knew him. Nor, did the hat that the woman in the get-away car wore, camouflage her distinctive looks.
The gas station was remote and it was too late and too far to go for the sheriff. The victim and his wife decided to wait until the next day, for the long desert drive to file a robbery report. Justice could easily wait until morning, they knew all too well, where the perpetrators lived and worked.
Meanwhile, the robbers silently congratulated themselves that their feminine innocent accomplices slept through the gas station robbery, in the backseat of a secretly borrowed 1922 closed coach Essex. They'd gotten enough money, but they were still worried, as they grimly drove away.
Little did they know, that by 9:30 a.m. the next morning, the youngest of them would be dead. The older girl would be haunted by the events for the rest of her life. In the end, all that happened would have life-long consequences.
Once Deadly, Now Preventable and Treatable
Most childhood diseases that were widespread in the 1930s, are now both preventable and highly treatable. Such was the case of both Otitis media and the complications of lobar pneumonia, that were the listed causes of death for Wanda Mae.
Penicillin in the early 1930s had only been recently discovered. It still was in it's clinical trials stage, in terms of being available for treating deadly infections. Other antibiotics like sulfa drugs, were also known, but not widely used in the United States.
The Events Leading Up to the Robbery of a Child's Life
Ten days earlier, in what seemed like an ordinary cold, little Wanda Mae began to become more fussy and kept rubbing her ear. Her young mother, by then the mother of two girls only eleven months apart, didn't realize at first how serious her baby's ear infection was. Her older daughter had already experienced the same symptoms twice before, and recovered each time in a few days.
For the first couple of days, she tried various home remedies of the era, for inner ear infections, including blowing smoke in her little girl's ear. Two days later, frantic and exhausted with a constantly crying baby, she spent the last of their grocery money to take her little girl to the local doctor. He prescribed Vitamin C and told the mother to "let the illness run it's course."
Soon, Wanda Mae developed other symptoms, such as:
- Cough
- Clammy skin
- A very high fever
- She wouldn't eat
- She seemed to be struggling to breathe
They kept taking her back to the doctor, borrowing his fee each time from friends and relatives, who had little to give financially themselves. By the day before she died, the doctor admitted he could do little for her, and suggested that she be taken to the local hospital in another nearby town.
That winter day, the hospital was already fairly full. Many, if not most of the patients, in this time before health insurance -- were indigent. Wanda Mae's parents were were told to find someone that they could borrow a down payment for hospitalization from, and to hurry back.
Everyone they knew contributed what they could, but the money combined only amounted to a few dollars. Time was running out. Frantic, the young father decided he had no choice, but to get the money any way he could -- after being turned down for a loan by his employer, a church, and his banker.
The Death of Wanda Mae - December 1, 1933
Four days before her first birthday, and twenty-six days before America's first insured "Blue Cross Baby" was born, a baby girl died in Chandler, Arizona. While the financial repercussions of the stock market crash of 1929 weren't a direct cause of her death -- the financial hard times everyone experienced, played a role in this infant's tragic death from otitis media and lobar pneumonia.
She was the littlest accomplice (along with her twenty-two month old sister) who rode in a wicker basket, while her young parents robbed a gas station -- because the local doctor who had been treating their baby for an ear infection, would not be able to admit the baby to the hospital, without a down payment.
The Victims of the Gas Station Robbery
On their way to report the gas station robbery, the business owning couple stopped to chat with an acquaintance, who informed them of the tragic loss of a young couple's eleven month old child.
They found the news so distressing, that they ended up staying in town for the next couple of days. They never got around to reporting the robbery.
Heartbroken for the family, the couple anonymously paid the entire $48.54 complete funeral costs for little Wanda Mae, before she was buried in the Double Butte Cemetery. Family members didn't know who paid the funeral costs for years.
Twenty years later, the husband would admit to the then local sheriff -- that he recognized him and his wife, the night they robbed his gas station. He'd even seen the innocent accomplices in the back of the 1922 Essex. Both victim and robber hugged each other and cried the day he revealed that secret.
The gas station owner told him, under the circumstances, he would have done the same to try to save his own child. This was the reason they never turned him in. Then, the two (now old friends) agreed over a beer, that if one is going to plan an armed robbery -- don't borrow your brother's Essex, when it's the only one in the territory.
What the gas station owner never did admit while my grandfather was alive -- was the exceptional charity he and his wife gave the day -- they borrowed against their property for collateral, to pay for the baby in the wicker basket's funeral.
America's The Blue Cross Baby
America's first "Blue Cross Baby" came into this world on December 27, 1933 in Durham, North Carolina -- making her the first baby to have her birth and health care covered by insurance. Not only was her birth covered by a family health insurance certificate -- it also included maternity benefits. The total cost for a ten day stay in the hospital came to sixty dollars.
At this Depression era time, that low hospital figure, was quite impressive, as the average worker (if they had work) made only $780.00 a year. However, most people would be shocked to know the facts about the cost of delivering a baby -- now seventy-five years later.
Here are some numbers to ponder:
- Today, the costs to deliver a baby, without any complications ranges from $9,000 to $17,000 for those who are uninsured.
- A C-section, without any complications ranges from $14,000 to $25,000 for that same uninsured patient.
- Yet, for those lucky enough to have insurance, the costs to deliver a baby, without any complications generally costs their parents from $500 to $3,000 out-of-pocket.
Medical Insurance for Children Today
Today, it's no secret that there are over ten million children in the United States without any medical insurance. Even more startling is that in an increasingly sicker economy, parents are skimping on medicine, putting off vaccinations, and other routine tests and check-ups for their children.
Most are just praying their children don't get sick and relying on going to emergency rooms for treatments they can't afford (knowing that by law they cannot be turned away).
Medical Insurance in the 1930s
Virtually no one in the early 1930s had what we would consider health insurance today, especially coverage for children. One statistic from the time period, suggests that less than fifteen percent of U.S. families shouldered the cost of more than fifty percent, of all yearly medical expenses.
Those who could not pay, if they could get care, had to turn to either family, friends, churches, or private charities. Many medical practitioners of the time, ended up absorbing the costs of a majority of patients who could not pay.
Before health insurance was common place, people paid out-of-pocket. With the election of Franklin Roosevelt, the problem of uninsured families was so severe that several attempts were made to make health insurance compulsory. However, during The Great Depression -- with millions of people unemployed -- unemployment insurance and other needs were greater. As we all know, no one could ever come up with a plan for national health insurance that would work.
In a previous hub, Survivor Marathon, I shared the true story of the desperate situation my grandmother lived through, in the years right before The Great Depression. Like many people, several years later, her life and that of my grandfather, weren't much better off.
In January of 1932, she and my grandfather were like the rest of their peers, struggling even more. By then, they were living in a shack in the Sunnyslope area (off 7th Avenue) of Chandler, Arizona.
Their household included her two younger orphaned brothers, and their first born new baby. Her birth, signaled the spiral down that often occurs in marriages when going through tough times. In times of financial hardships, married couples either pull together, or fall apart.
In the case of my grandparents, their already fragile marriage fell apart the following year, with the loss of their youngest baby girl, Wanda Mae. Each blamed themselves, the doctor, and each other. Their surviving daughter would live with the life long sadness, neither were able to get over.
Pneumonia
Unlike today, in 1933, pneumonia was the leading cause of death in the U.S. However, just like in the 1930s, pneumonia is still the leading cause of death in children throughout the rest of the world. Thanks to the creation of antibiotics like penicillin, these are preventable deaths.
Now, pneumonia is a very treatable public health issue, that can manifest itself in over one hundred different types. However, the five most common types are:
- Bacterial pneumonia - Usually easily controlled by antibiotics
- Viral pneumonia - Most common in children
- Mycoplasma pneumonia - Milder form of primarily fungi infections (also known as "walking pneumonia")
- Opportunistic pneumonia - Usually strikes those with weakened immune systems and the elderly
- Respiratory syncytical pneumonia virus (RSV) - The most prevalent kind of pneumonia in infants and toddlers
Treatment and Prevention of Pneumonia
Of the three ways to prevent pneumonia, the first one has to do with common sense -- if you make it your business to life a lifestyle of eating right (plenty of fresh fruits and vegetables), exercise, and getting enough rest -- you'll be more likely to have a healthy immune system.
Secondly, if you are in a high risk health situation (over the age of 65 or have an underlying illness) get vaccinated for the two most common types (influenza virus and pneumococcus). There's even a new vaccine for children.
Third, always make sure that if your child has any cough that's not getting better in a couple of days, coughing up blood, or strange colored and bad smelling sputum -- seek medical attention immediately. The video link below, while technical, is a very good overview of pneumonia as it is viewed by the medical profession today.
21st Century Bacterial Pneumonia: Old Habits and New Approaches
Otitis Media
Otitis Media is not normally the name of a common illness that most parents are familiar with. Otitis Media is simply the medical name for inflammation of the middle ear, and a complication of a type of upper respiratory tract infections.
It is the most common illness in infants and small children. Commonly, infants and particularly toddlers get at least two to three middle ear infections every year.
Now, one of the frightening things about otitis media, is the evolving emergence of antibiotic resistance, that has this illness once again morphing into a life-threatening illness.
Otitis Media
Children's Ear Infections
If You'd Like to Know More About Infant Ear Infections and Pneumonia!
- Community-Acquired Pneumonia in Infants and Children - September 1, 2004 - American Family Physician
- Pneumonia - Clinical Health Topics - Children\'s Hospital Boston
- Otitis Media in Children
Learn more about otitis media and how this acute or chronic middle ear infection, that mostly affects children, is caused, diagnosed and treated on MedicineNet.com - Ear infection (middle ear) - MayoClinic.com
Ear infection Comprehensive overview covers symptoms, treatment, prevention, home remedies for middle ear infections. - Middle Ear Infections
Ear infections are common among kids and, often, painful. Find out what causes them and how they're treated.
CommentsLoading...
Wonderful hub! I can't help but feel anger at that doctor. When will we put aside the $ for human compassion and love. God bless that man who did not report a robberty - he did more than the doctor did.
Great article and very thought provocing. Appriciate the time you take out of your life to share.
denise
Hi Jerrilee,
This was a well-written and moving story. What privations people lived through in times gone by! It's terrible to think what ordinary, decent people can be driven to when desparation hits.
Whenever I read about the healthcare system in America, I feel a surge of gratitude for our own NHS. All too often we Brits moan and groan about the service we receive, but even if there are waiting lists for some things, at least it's free. No-one has to think twice before going to the doctor, and if you can't always get to a surgery conveniently, our pharmacists in the chemist shops will always give advice without charge.
Over and over on HubPages I read comments that suggest that such a system is logistically impossible in the USA, or that people (usually those that are doing okay, thank you) are happy with the status quo, and think that it's only fair to pay for what you receive. That's well and good of course, but ill-health is not usually a choice. If logistics are the problem maybe UHC could be administered state by state?
I think the Aussies got it from the Swedes.
Thank you for this well written story Jerilee Wei, I was horified to hear on the radio the other day that a certain percentage of americans go bankrupt due to illness related expenses - this is so shocking - TG we in Australia don't have this worry as we enjoy govt. subsidised Medicare; additionally if you are on a pension and have expended a certain amount per year on health costs then subsequent prescriptions are free until the following calendar commences. On this basis you may have up to six/four months with free prescription medicines available. cheers.
Thank you for writing about this personal family story- it was very touching and I could totally relate to what your grandparents had to do- and the kindness of that gas station owner! Even in hard times it shows that people can still have good hearts- and I'm sorry that it had to break up their marriage and affect your grandmother the way it did.
Health care should be a right I think- not something we have to fight for.
Jerilee, I really appreciate your view on this, especially today of all days. I think anybody who served in the armed forces deserves special benefits! I hope everything is going well with your treatment.
I don't have the answer to the health care crisis, either. However, I think that allowing the insurance industry to die a natural death, if they overextend themselves, might be a start in the right direction.
Jerilee, great hub and very informative story. Isn't it a shame that once the child did die, the funeral costs were so high!
People will do almost anything to save a loved one. A century earlier, these same people might not have even thought that anything could be done for their child. It's the widespread availability of modern health care that makes accepting the inevitable so hard. It is now making it so much harder for the elderly to die in peace.
It used to be that babies were routinely delivered at home, and that anyone, young or old, who got pneumonia was unlikely to recover. A friend of mine who is now in her eighties confided to me that the reason eldercare was not such a problem when she was a child was that once an elderly person became a little frail, they would catch pneumonia and die. Very few lived long enough to need diapers.
What people who advocate universal health care insurance coverage aren't telling us, though, is that we're not really talking about insurance. We are talking about paying outright for people's health services, from public funds. This would have been unthinkable in America a century ago.
Insurance is supposed to be about something that may or may not happen to us, like having our house burn down. You could go an entire lifetime without having your house burn down -- or it may happen tomorrow. People who choose to insure their houses are people who decide to pool their resources, so that if they are unfortunate enough to have this disaster happen to them, they will have some resources for rebuilding. The insurance company bets against the house burning down, because if it doesn't happen, then they get to keep everybody's money. They make their profit from the fact that people believe their house burning down is a little more likely to happen than it actually is going to happen.
But we are all going to get sick at some point in our lives. Most women will have children, and they will need to give birth. All people age and then die -- unless they die before they age. These are things that are certain to happen.
Cancer research hasn't discovered a cure for cancer, but it has managed to turn many cancers into chronic diseases, rather than fatal ones. There will never be a way to avoid death, but we are learning to put it off more and more. This creates a whole class of people who are entirely dependent on medical intervention in order to keep going day by day. Medical services that no one even heard of a few decades earlier become routine necessities.
Universal health insurance isn't insurance. We might as well pay for our own health costs, because we will definitely have them. Paying a middleman for these services merely makes the costs go up. The reason the enforced universal health care coverage is advocated is in order to redistribute resources, not provide a safe cushion for an emergency situation.
great hub....sad but great
Jerilee, I admire your storytelling abilities and the way you draw from personal experiences and history to discuss important social issues. Thank you for sharing the sad story of Wanda Mae, in hopes of sparing other families from this type of tragedy. I hope to bring a baby or two into the world, someday, if it's meant to be, but it looks like I'll need to start saving up now for the delivery fees! Not to mention health care... it's a wonder that anyone can afford to have children.
It bemuses a lot of us that we're still in this situation.
What a family tragedy. And what a story of compassion, too. Thank you for sharing it with us!
It bermuses me that the US is still in this situation my grandparents in the 1930s in NZ had my grandfather get so sick with pneumnia he never worked again though he didnt die until 1960. The hospital bills meant they had to mortgage the house: a bill my mother paid for them in the 1960s. After the depression the Labour government brought in free health care and although its not perfect and you wait a long time for hip replacements and the like under 5's get free care including most docs and anyone can get free emergency care though you won't get a private room and you might have to wait
David comment - above: the Australian dental bills are crazy I have been quoted $1500 for a crown which would cost 1/2 that in NZ - i will get in done in Malalysia next year for the same cost including air and a holiday - the actual crown will cost
Nobody should have to die for lack of money in the new world. How can any hospital turn down treatment when they know by doing so a person will die, it is just plain wrong!
Very sad story. Poor parents how bad I feel for them.
My grandmother died when she was 100. She was the most honest woman you could know but when her 7 babies were starving she stole a chicken to feed them. Something she never forgot and never stopped feeling bad about.
Thank God I live in Australia, where emergency hospital treatment is covered by Government-subsidised health insurance - Medicare. Sadly it does not include dental cover, so the dentists still get to screw us. I am so glad I don't live in the US, where doctors sure know how to make money off the sick.
Amazing and touching hub, I was riveted throughout and the event was truly a tragic waste of life that should have been avoidable if governments did their job properly.
Jerri,
Wonderful article. Shows we often don't know what we need to know until it is too late. Very educational. Good work.






















Jerilee Wei Hub Author 3 years ago
Thanks! I imagine doctors back then had more patients who could not pay anything than those who could, the doctor wasn't as much the problem as the hospital was, as they were the ones refusing to admit the baby without a down payment. That's probably why laws exist today that if you make to the ER they have to take you regardless of money or insurance.
Of course, that policy only leads to those who have insurance paying for those who don't and those without insurance using the ER as their sole medical care.